top of page

What GenAI is Really Doing to Our Brains

Nov 12
4 min read

The arrival of generative AI (GenAI) is the kind of disruption that shows up unannounced and immediately pushes you off balance. Whether we like it or not, this technology is part of our everyday lives, and will likely remain a major presence in our future.


There is much discussion about the implications of GenAI, though the blurred line between its benefits and detriments depends largely on the user’s intent. One of the most compelling debates on GenAI use regards individual overreliance in academic settings. It is far from uncommon for students to rely on GenAI in some way – some use it for research, while others exploit it to complete entire assignments without so much as lifting a finger. Beyond academia, people frequently turn to GenAI for everyday decision-making and relying on a computer algorithm for the simplest tasks, all to avoid exerting any hard mental effort.


Intuitively, we can understand why this excessive reliance on GenAI might be problematic. But what implications does it have for brain health? Surely, letting a computer ‘think’ for us will lead to undesirable consequences in the future.


Cognitive Offloading

To find out, let’s first understand how new information is learned.


Broadly speaking, learning follows a basic pipeline: information enters short-term memory when we pay attention to stimuli, such as a chapter from a textbook. By actively rehearsing this information, such as through reading and taking notes, we encode it into long-term memory. The retention of that knowledge is dependent on consistent, elaborative rehearsal, such as regular studying and active recall. 


That sounds like a lot of work, doesn’t it? What happens if we introduce GenAI into the mix?

When used simply as a shortcut to avoid the struggle of solving a homework problem or writing an essay, GenAI directly disrupts this pipeline by eliminating the need for mental effort. This leads to the idea of cognitive offloading – the replacement of critical thinking and mental exertion with GenAI tools to complete cognitively stimulating activities. 


When used simply as a shortcut (...) GenAI directly disrupts this pipeline by eliminating the need for mental effort.

As one can imagine, cognitive offloading through GenAI is quite common in academic settings. A survey from 2025 found that 88% of full-time undergraduate students in the UK used GenAI in some capacity for university work, while 18% of those students admitted to including fully AI-generated text directly in their assignments. 


Beyond academia, it is also quite concerning that many people rely on GenAI for the simplest of tasks: ‘What do I wear today?’ and ‘Can you plan my night out?’ are common prompts fed into ChatGPT. We have reached a point where GenAI has replaced the bare minimum of critical thinking and decision-making – a worrying trend.


Whether you are completing a university assignment or planning your weekend, the undeniable efficiency of GenAI comes at a cost: it bypasses the crucial step of rehearsal, which is vital for memory consolidation and retention. The time and effort you saved is completely illusory; the work itself may be completed faster, but in the longer term, you don’t actually end up learning anything. This may seem like a short-term penalty, but the consequences of cognitive offloading become much more severe over time. 


Cognitive Atrophy

Cognitively stimulating activities may be intellectually demanding, but isn’t that the point? Reading a textbook or solving a puzzle helps strengthen neuronal connections and foster the development of more efficient neural networks, which ultimately improves critical thinking skills. Conversely, when the brain is deprived of such stimulation, its neural connections receive less reinforcement and gradually weaken. Much like a normal muscle, the brain requires consistent exercise to grow stronger and will weaken without adequate use.


This gradual weakening is known as cognitive atrophy. Research suggests that excessive reliance on GenAI is correlated with reduced activity in brain regions responsible for memory and executive functions, particularly those involved in critical thinking. This superficial engagement with learning has long-term implications for our ability to retain knowledge and to think critically. Research shows that excessive cognitive offloading may be detrimental to working memory and critical thinking skills in the long term. Without the struggle required for learning, since the brain prioritises efficiency, it expends less energy on memory and executive functions. If cognitive offloading becomes routine, our memory encoding declines and critical thinking skills degrade.


In short, GenAI dependence quite literally, makes us dumber. It would not be very surprising if we observe an increasing prevalence in cognitive impairments in the future.


Conclusion

Ultimately, GenAI is a double-edged sword that should be handled responsibly. Though the potential it has is vast, it can also be a short-term convenience bought at the expense of our long-term health. While we cannot un-invent this technology, we must manage our reliance on it. If we want to protect our brain health, we must recognise that the struggle of learning is not a barrier to avoid, but a necessary process to keep our minds alive.



References:

Freeman, J. (2025). Student generative AI survey 2025. Higher Education Policy Institute: London, UK, 2.

Gerlich, M. (2025). AI tools in society: Impacts on cognitive offloading and the future of critical thinking. Societies, 15(1), 6. https://doi.org/10.3390/soc15010006

Kabashkin, I. (2025). Cognitive atrophy paradox of AI–human interaction: From cognitive growth and atrophy to balance. Information, 16(11), 1009. https://doi.org/10.3390/info16111009

Westerbeek, H. (2026). How AI is rewiring the human brain: The generational transformation of cognition and knowing. AI & Society, 41(5), 5327–5337. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-026-02912-2


.............................................................................................................................................................

This article was written by Elwyne Noa Lai and edited by Julia Dabrowska, with graphics produced by Ishika Joshi. If you enjoyed this article, be the first to be notified about new posts by signing up to become a WiNUK member (top right of this page)! Interested in writing for WiNUK yourself? Contact us through the blog page and the editors will be in touch.

Comments


bottom of page